Pep Guardiola Apologises to £50m Man City star After Benching Him in Al-Hilal Defeat

Pep Guardiola has apologised to John Stones after the Manchester City defender was left out of the team throughout the FIFA Club World Cup, despite being one of the club’s most experienced and trusted players in recent years.

City’s trip to the United States ended in disappointment after a 4-3 defeat to Al-Hilal in the Round of 16, and while the result was frustrating for the team, the absence of Stones from the matchday line-ups raised just as many questions.

Speaking via Manchester City’s official website, Guardiola said:
“I’m so sorry for John [Stones], not giving him minutes but the game was so demanding.”

It was a telling remark from a manager known for meticulous planning and squad rotation. Guardiola had the challenge of choosing from a strong 27-man squad, including several new arrivals and developing talents, all hoping to impress in a competition City have never won. Players like Abdukodir Khusanov and Rayan Cherki got limited time on the pitch—Cherki featured only against Wydad AC—while Stones remained an unused option throughout.

The former Everton man has long been a key figure under Guardiola, especially in the club’s domestic and European success over the past five years. His transformation into a hybrid defender-midfielder helped revolutionise City’s build-up play. However, injuries have hampered Stones’ rhythm over the last 12 months. He started only six Premier League games last season and missed a large portion of the campaign due to recurring muscle issues.

Now 31, Stones faces a crucial period in his career. His current contract runs until 2026, but if his involvement remains limited next season, there is growing speculation that City may opt not to offer a renewal. If the club waits too long, they risk losing him for free when his deal expires.

Despite the latest setback, Stones has confirmed he intends to stay and fight for his place. Sources close to the player suggest he is focused on returning fully fit for pre-season and proving he can still contribute at the highest level.

For Guardiola, the decision to leave out Stones was a tactical and physical one—protecting a player he values highly from further setbacks. But the move also underlined the harsh reality of City’s squad depth. With competition for places fiercer than ever, even a £50 million defender can be left on the fringes when form and fitness come into play.

As Manchester City prepare for another intense campaign, the coming months will likely define Stones’ long-term future at the club—and whether he remains central to Guardiola’s plans or quietly moves toward an exit.